Health Insurance Claim Settlement Ratio
12
Jan 2025

Overview

When choosing a health insurance plan, the Health Insurance Claim Settlement Ratio (Health Insurance CSR) is one of the most critical evaluation metrics. This figure provides valuable insight into the reliability and efficiency of an insurance provider in processing and settling claims. In this article, we’ll explore the Health Insurance Claim Settlement Ratio, why it matters, and how to use it to select the best health insurance policy.

What is the Health Insurance Claim Settlement Ratio?

The Health Insurance Claim Settlement Ratio (CSR) is a percentage that indicates the number of claims an insurer has settled in comparison to the total claims received during a financial year. It is calculated as:

Claim Settlement Ratio = (Number of Claims Settled / Total Claims Received) x 100

For example, if an insurer received 10,000 claims in a year and settled 9,500 of them, the CSR would be:

(9500 / 10000) x 100 = 95%

A high CSR demonstrates the insurer’s ability and commitment to honouring claims, making it a crucial factor for policyholders.

Why is the Claim Settlement Ratio Important?

The Claim Settlement Ratio (CSR) is important for several key reasons, especially when evaluating a health insurance provider. Here’s why it matters:

Indicates Reliability

A high CSR reflects the insurer’s reliability in honouring claims. It gives policyholders confidence that their claims will likely be processed and settled without unnecessary hurdles.

Helps Compare Insurers

When choosing between multiple insurers, CSR is an objective metric to assess their performance. A higher CSR indicates better efficiency in claim handling, helping you narrow down your options.

Builds Trust

Trust is crucial in health insurance. A consistent and strong CSR fosters trust among customers, reassuring them that the insurer will provide financial support during medical emergencies.

Regulatory Transparency

The Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI) mandates insurers to disclose their CSR annually. This promotes transparency and holds insurers accountable, helping customers make informed decisions.

Predicts Claim Approval Likelihood

The CSR shows how likely your claim is to be approved. Insurers with a high ratio are more likely to settle genuine claims efficiently, reducing financial stress during emergencies.

In essence, CSR is a critical metric to evaluate an insurance provider’s reliability, transparency, and customer-centric approach. It ensures that you choose a policy that provides dependable coverage when you need it the most.

Factors That Impact the Health Insurance Claim Settlement Ratio

Here are the factors that impact the Health Insurance Claim Settlement Ratio (CSR):

Claim Filing Accuracy

Incomplete or incorrect claim submissions, such as missing documents or errors in medical reports, can lead to delays or rejections. The more accurate and complete the submissions, the better the chances of settlement.

Policy Coverage and Exclusions

Claims that fall outside the scope of the policy (e.g., pre-existing conditions not covered during the waiting period) are often rejected. Insurers with clear and transparent policies tend to have better CSRs.

Fraudulent Claims

Fraudulent or exaggerated claims negatively affect CSR as these are thoroughly investigated and often denied. Insurers implementing strict fraud detection measures may see a temporary dip in CSR.

Claim Amount and Complexity

Higher-value or complex claims, such as those involving multiple procedures or treatments, may undergo more scrutiny, impacting the settlement rate and processing time.

Insurers Internal Processes

Efficient operational workflows, digital claim processing, and well-trained staff significantly contribute to a higher CSR. Insurers with streamlined systems settle claims faster and more reliably.

Timely Claim Filing by Policyholders

Delayed submission of claims beyond the allowed timeline can lead to rejections, impacting the CSR. Timely filing ensures smoother processing and contributes positively to the ratio.

Hospital Network and Cashless Services

Insurers with an extensive network of empanelled hospitals often process claims faster, particularly cashless claims, improving their CSR.

Policyholder Awareness

Well-informed policyholders who understand policy terms and provide correct documentation help insurers settle claims more effectively, boosting CSR.

Claim Volume

Insurers with many claims may have more complex claim management systems. While this could sometimes lower the CSR, established providers with efficient operations can maintain high ratios despite heavy claim volumes.

Economic and Market Conditions

Factors like inflation in healthcare costs or an economic downturn can influence claim frequencies and settlement efficiencies, indirectly impacting CSR.

How to Use CSR While Choosing Health Insurance?

Here’s how you can effectively use the Health Insurance Claim Settlement Ratio (CSR) to choose the best health insurance plan:

Look for Consistency

  • Check the CSR of an insurer over the past 3 to 5 years.
  • A consistent or improving ratio reflects the insurer’s stable and reliable claim settlement process.
  • Avoid insurers with drastic fluctuations, which may indicate inefficiencies or operational instability.

Compare Against the Industry Average

  • Evaluate the CSR of your preferred insurer against the industry average.
  • A ratio higher than the average is a good indicator of reliability.
  • For example, if the average CSR is 85%, an insurer with a 95% CSR is likely more dependable.

Check Claim Settlement Time

  • Analyze how quickly the insurer processes and settles claims.
  • Some insurers may have a high CSR but take longer to settle claims.
  • Look for providers with quick and efficient claim settlement processes to reduce stress during emergencies.

Evaluate Claim Rejection Rates

  • Alongside CSR, check the insurer’s claim rejection rate.
  • A low rejection rate and a high CSR reflect a fair and customer-centric approach to claims processing.
  • Ensure rejections are not due to unclear policy terms or stringent claim scrutiny.

Consider the Claim Volume

  • High CSR with a large number of claims settled indicates robust operational efficiency.
  • Smaller insurers with high CSRs but low claim volumes might not have been tested under high-pressure scenarios.

Assess the Nature of Claims Settled

  • Find out whether the settled claims are primarily small or large claims.
  • Some insurers may settle smaller claims to maintain a high CSR while being stricter with larger claims.
  • Look for a balance in the type of claims settled.

Analyze the Insurer’s Support System

  • A high CSR is only valuable if supported by good customer service and accessibility.
  • Ensure the insurer has a responsive claim assistance team and a strong network of hospitals for cashless claims.

Combine CSR with Other Metrics

  • CSR should not be the sole factor in your decision. Consider it alongside:
    • Premium affordability
    • Policy features and benefits
    • Coverage inclusions and exclusions
    • Hospital network size and availability

Read Customer Reviews

  • Reviews from existing policyholders provide insights into the insurer’s claim-handling experience beyond CSR figures.
  • Look for consistent positive feedback on settlement reliability.

Consult Regulatory Data

  • Refer to annual reports published by the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI) for verified CSR data.
  • This ensures that you’re using accurate and unbiased information.

Health Insurance Companies Claim Settlement Ratio

Here’s an overview of the Claim Settlement Ratios (CSR) of health insurance companies in India, based on their recent performance. This data helps you compare their efficiency and reliability in settling claims.

Health Insurance Company

Incurred Claim Ratio (2023-24)

Claim Settlement Ratio (2022-23)

Acko Health Insurance

56.91

97.68

Aditya Birla Health Insurance

68.31

99.01

Bajaj Allianz Health Insurance

84.96

93.54

Care Health Insurance

57.69

100

Cholamandalam MS Health Insurance

66.67

93.63

Go Digit Health Insurance

93.87

96.83

Zuno Health Insurance

88.45

98.54

Future Generali India Health Insurance

84.62

94.98

HDFC ERGO Health Insurance

80.98

98.59

ICICI Lombard Health Insurance

78.85

98.53

IFFCO Tokio Health Insurance

107.46

90.65

Kotak Mahindra Health Insurance

59.06

97.61

Liberty General Insurance Ltd.

79.92

97.46

Magma HDI Health Insurance

87.46

94.72

ManipalCigna Health Insurance

63.78

99.96

Niva Bupa Health Insurance

59.02

100

National Health Insurance

90.83

91.31

Navi Health Insurance

59.40

95.13

New India Assurance Health Insurance

105.87

90.73

Oriental Health Insurance

101.96

91.62

Raheja QBE Health Insurance Co. Ltd.

106.27

97.30

Royal Sundaram Health Insurance

92.06

95.95

Reliance Health Insurance

89.42

98.75

SBI Health Insurance

87.86

96.47

Star Health Insurance

66.47

99.21

Tata AIG Health Insurance

77.94

95.46

Universal Sompo Health Insurance

105.76

91.58

United India Health Insurance

109.23

91.10

*Disclaimer: We, Bloglynk, do not endorse any specific insurance company or insurance product offered by any insurer. This list just illustrates health insurance companies’ claim settlement ratio available in India.

Common Myths About Health Insurance CSR

Myth 1: A 100% CSR is Always the Best

A 100% CSR might indicate that the insurer does not scrutinize claims thoroughly, potentially leading to higher premiums in the long run.

Myth 2: CSR is the Only Metric to Consider

While important, CSR should be evaluated alongside policy benefits, premium costs, and network hospitals.

Health Insurance Claim Settlement Process

The health insurance claim settlement process involves several steps to ensure the insured individual receives financial support for medical expenses. Claims can be made in two ways: cashless claims or reimbursement claims. Here’s a comprehensive guide to the claim settlement process:

Types of Claims

  1. Cashless Claims

  • Available only at network hospitals of the insurance provider.
  • The insurer directly settles the bills with the hospital.
  1. Reimbursement Claims

  • Applicable when treatment occurs at a non-network hospital or if cashless approval is not obtained.
  • The insured pays the expenses upfront and later files for reimbursement.

Steps in the Claim Settlement Process

For Cashless Claims

  • Pre-Authorization
      • Inform the insurance provider or TPA (Third-Party Administrator) at least 48-72 hours before planned hospitalization or within 24 hours in emergencies.
      • Submit the cashless claim form available at the hospital or the insurer’s website.
  • Approval Process
      • The hospital sends the pre-authorization form to the insurer.
      • The insurer reviews and approves or rejects the claim based on policy terms.
  • Bill Settlement
    • Once approved, the insurer directly pays the hospital for the covered expenses.
    • The insured only pays for non-covered charges (e.g., food or personal expenses).

For Reimbursement Claims

  • Treatment and Payment

      • The insured pays all hospital bills and collects the necessary documents (invoices, discharge summary, medical reports, etc.).
  • Claim Submission

      • Submit the claim form and required documents to the insurer or TPA within the stipulated time (typically 7-15 days after discharge).
  • Claim Processing

      • The insurer reviews the documents, verifies eligibility, and processes the claim.
      • They may request additional information if needed.
  • Claim Settlement

    • Approved claims are reimbursed to the insured’s bank account.
    • In case of rejection, the insurer provides the reason for denial.

Required Documents

  • Duly filled claim form (cashless or reimbursement).
  • Discharge summary from the hospital.
  • Original hospital bills and receipts.
  • Doctor’s prescription and medical reports.
  • Pharmacy bills with prescriptions.
  • Policy details and ID proof.
  • Bank account details for reimbursement claims.

Common Reasons for Claim Rejections

  • Incomplete documentation.
  • Treatment not covered under the policy.
  • Claim filed after the stipulated timeline.
  • Incorrect or fraudulent claims.

Tips for Hassle-Free Claim Settlement

  1. Notify the insurer promptly about hospitalization.
  2. Maintain accurate records of all medical expenses and documents.
  3. Understand your policy terms to avoid rejections.
  4. Use network hospitals whenever possible for faster settlement.
  5. Follow up with the insurer or TPA to check the claim status.

Conclusion

The Health Insurance Claim Settlement Ratio (Health Insurance CSR) is a vital assessment metric before purchasing a health insurance plan. It provides a clear picture of an insurer’s claim-handling efficiency and reliability. However, while a high CSR is desirable, it should not be the sole criterion. A balanced approach that considers CSR, policy features, customer service, and affordability will help you make an informed decision.

Invest wisely and ensure your health insurance is a dependable safety net when you need it the most.

Health Insurance Claim Settlement Ratio FAQs

  1. What is the Health Insurance Claim Settlement Ratio (CSR)?

Ans. The Claim Settlement Ratio (CSR) is the percentage of claims settled by an insurer out of the total claims received during a financial year. It reflects the insurer’s efficiency and reliability in handling claims.

  1. Why is a high CSR important?

Ans. A high CSR indicates that the insurer is dependable and processes claims efficiently, providing peace of mind to policyholders that their claims will likely be honoured.

  1. How is CSR calculated?

Ans. CSR is calculated using the formula:
Claim Settlement Ratio = (Number of Claims Settled / Total Claims Received) × 100

  1. What is a good CSR for health insurance companies?

Ans. A CSR above 90% is generally considered excellent. However, a CSR between 80% and 90% is also reliable, depending on other factors like claim volume and settlement time.

  1. Does a 100% CSR mean the insurer is the best?

Ans. Not necessarily. A 100% CSR could indicate that the insurer is not scrutinizing claims adequately, which might lead to higher premiums in the future. A consistently high CSR (90-95%) over several years is a better indicator of a good insurer.

  1. Should I choose an insurer based solely on CSR?

Ans. No. While CSR is an important metric, you should also consider:

  • Policy features and benefits
  • Premium costs
  • Hospital network coverage
  • Customer reviews
  • Average claim settlement time
  1. How often is CSR updated?

Ans. CSR is updated annually by insurers and published in their financial reports. The Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI) also publishes CSR data in its annual report.

  1. Can CSR vary for different types of claims?

Ans. Yes. CSR may differ for cashless and reimbursement claims or for high-value versus low-value claims. It’s essential to understand the insurer’s claim-handling processes in detail.

  1. Where can I find an insurer’s CSR?

Ans. You can find CSR data:

  • On the insurer’s official website.
  • In the IRDAI’s annual reports.
  • Through reliable comparison websites for health insurance.
  1. Does a low CSR always mean the insurer is bad?

Ans. Not necessarily. A lower CSR could result from stricter claim verification processes or higher volumes of complex claims. However, consistently low CSR over multiple years might indicate inefficiency.

  1. How does CSR impact claim settlement speed?

Ans. CSR does not directly reflect the speed of claim settlement. While a high CSR indicates efficient claim handling, you should check the insurer’s average claim settlement time separately.

  1. Are public insurers better than private insurers in CSR?

Ans. Public insurers often have high CSRs due to their large customer base and experience. However, private insurers may offer faster processing, better customer service, and innovative policy features.

  1. Can CSR be manipulated by insurers?

Ans. While CSR is a transparent metric, insurers might prioritize smaller or simpler claims to boost their ratio. Reviewing independent customer feedback and detailed IRDAI reports can provide a more accurate picture.

  1. Does CSR include rejected claims?

Ans. Yes. CSR reflects the total claims received and settled but does not directly show the number of claims rejected. You can check the claim rejection rate for additional insights.

  1. What should I do if my claim is rejected despite a high CSR?

Ans. Below are things that you can do if your claim is rejected:

  • Review your policy terms to confirm coverage.
  • Contact the insurer’s grievance cell for clarification.
  • Escalate to the IRDAI Grievance Redressal Portal if unresolved.
Categories: Finance & Banking

2 thoughts on “Health Insurance Claim Settlement Ratio

Leave a Comment